top of page

Employee vs Contractor for Lawyers: What the ATO Actually Looks At

Mar 2
5 min read

Updated: Nov 5

Lawyer in a black blazer speaks to a man across a desk in a bright office, with laptop, papers, books, and Brisbane city view.

For Brisbane law firms, engaging lawyers as contractors can seem like a practical solution. More flexibility. Lower fixed costs. Scalable capacity.


But when it comes to the ATO, what matters isn’t what you call someone. It’s what the working relationship looks like.


With increased scrutiny around contractor arrangements across professional services, Brisbane legal practices need to ensure their structure would withstand review, particularly where Queensland payroll tax may also apply.

 

Why Misclassification Is a Risk for Brisbane Law Firms


Misclassifying a lawyer as a contractor can trigger:


  • Superannuation back payments

  • PAYG withholding liabilities

  • Queensland payroll tax exposure

  • Interest and penalties

  • Potential Fair Work claims


Even where both parties agree to a contractor arrangement, the ATO applies a substance over label approach.


For Brisbane firms, this risk is heightened where contractor models are used for senior associates, consultants or percentage based arrangements.

 

The Key Factors the ATO Considers


There is no single test. The ATO assesses the totality of the relationship.


1. Control


Who controls how the legal work is performed?


If the firm dictates:


  • Working hours (e.g. 8:30-5:30 in the Brisbane CBD office)

  • Where work must be performed

  • How matters are managed

  • Internal policies and billing procedures


This leans towards employment.


A genuine contractor typically has greater autonomy in how services are delivered.

 

2. Ability to Delegate


Can the lawyer subcontract or delegate the work?


A true contractor generally has the right to:


  • Delegate to another suitably qualified lawyer

  • Bear the cost of that delegation


If the individual must personally perform all work, this points more toward employment.


In legal practice, professional responsibility obligations can complicate this. This is why many Brisbane contractor models unintentionally resemble employment.

 

3. Commercial Risk


Who bears the financial risk?


Contractors typically:


  • Invoice the firm

  • Carry their own professional indemnity insurance

  • Rectify defects at their own cost

  • Manage profitability


Employees are paid regardless of matter margins and do not assume business risk.

 

4. Tools, Systems and Integration


Does the lawyer operate independently, or are they integrated into the firm?


Indicators of integration include:


  • Firm email address

  • Listing on the firm website as staff

  • Use of firm letterhead

  • Access to support staff and systems

  • Representing the firm as “we”


The more integrated the lawyer is into the Brisbane practice, the more likely the relationship resembles employment.

 

Superannuation: A Major Risk Area


Even if a lawyer is considered a contractor at common law, they may still be deemed an employee for superannuation purposes under the expanded definition in the Superannuation Guarantee legislation.


Superannuation may be payable if the contractor:


  • Is paid mainly for their labour

  • Is required to perform the work personally

  • Is not paid to achieve a specific result


This is one of the most common exposure points we see in Brisbane professional practices.

 

Queensland Payroll Tax Considerations


For Brisbane law firms, payroll tax adds another layer of complexity.


Queensland payroll tax provisions can apply to contractor payments where the arrangement is deemed “relevant contract” provisions under state legislation.


Even if a lawyer is a legitimate contractor for ATO purposes, payroll tax may still apply.


This is often overlooked and can create unexpected liabilities for growing firms.

 

Common Risk Areas We See in Brisbane Legal Practices


  • Senior lawyers converted to “contractors” but operating exactly as before

  • Percentage-of-billings arrangements with full integration into the firm

  • Outdated contractor agreements

  • No superannuation review under the expanded definition

  • No payroll tax assessment completed


These arrangements can work but only when properly structured.

 

What Brisbane Law Firms Should Do Now


If your firm engages lawyers as contractors:

  1. Review your written agreements

  2. Compare contract terms to actual working conditions

  3. Assess superannuation exposure separately

  4. Review Queensland payroll tax implications

  5. Document your position and reasoning


Addressing this proactively is significantly less costly than responding to an ATO or OSR review.

 

For Brisbane law firms, contractor arrangements can be commercially effective but only when structured carefully and reviewed regularly.


If you’re unsure whether your current lawyer contractor arrangements would withstand scrutiny, now is the time to assess them.

 

Book a Discovery Call with Rise Accountants and we’ll assess your current arrangements, identify exposure areas and outline practical next steps tailored to your firm.


Frequently Asked Questions


How does the ATO decide if a lawyer is an employee or contractor?

The Australian Taxation Office considers the overall working arrangement rather than relying on the title used in an agreement. Key factors include delegation, basis of payment, equipment, commercial risk, control and integration into the business.

No. An ABN or contractor agreement alone doesn't determine whether someone is genuinely an independent contractor. The characteristics of the actual working arrangement need to support the classification.

Yes. The Australian Taxation Office states that a business may still have to pay superannuation for an independent contractor where the contract is principally for the individual's labour.

Factors can include the firm controlling how, when and where work is performed, paying for time worked rather than a specific result, requiring the lawyer to personally perform the work and integrating the lawyer closely into the firm's operations. No single factor determines the outcome on its own.

Independent contractors generally have greater control over how services are delivered, may be able to delegate or subcontract work, provide their own equipment where relevant, invoice the engaging business and bear commercial risk associated with providing their services.

Regular hours can be relevant, particularly where the law firm determines when and where the work must be performed. However, worker classification depends on the overall relationship rather than any single characteristic.

Potentially, but simply changing the agreement or payment method doesn't necessarily change the underlying relationship. The Rise article highlights arrangements where lawyers move to contractor status but continue operating in substantially the same manner as an employee as an area requiring careful review.

No. Payment based on billings is only one feature of the arrangement. Control, delegation rights, commercial risk, integration and the other characteristics of the relationship still need to be considered.

Incorrect classification can result in tax and superannuation consequences, including potential PAYG withholding and superannuation liabilities. The Australian Taxation Office also notes that penalties may apply where a business incorrectly treats an employee as an independent contractor.

Potentially. The Rise article notes that Queensland payroll tax needs to be considered separately because certain contractor arrangements can fall within Queensland's relevant contract provisions. This means a genuine contractor arrangement for other purposes shouldn't automatically be assumed to be outside the payroll tax rules.

Yes. Contractor arrangements should be reviewed when agreements are renewed, working practices change or the lawyer becomes more integrated into the firm. Importantly, compare the written agreement with how the arrangement actually operates in practice.

Ideally before engaging a lawyer under a contractor model, particularly for long-term consultants, senior lawyers and percentage-of-billings arrangements. Getting the classification right upfront can reduce the risk of unexpected superannuation, PAYG and payroll tax liabilities later.



Subscribe to our newsletter

bottom of page