top of page

Should I Sell or Hold My Investment Property?

Feb 23
5 min read

Updated: Nov 5

Thoughtful man reviews papers at a desk beside a laptop, with a Brisbane city skyline and river bridge visible through the window.

This isn’t just about market timing. It’s about capital gains tax, cash flow, borrowing capacity and long term wealth strategy. 


Many investors focus on rising interest rates or recent property price growth. Fewer take the time to properly assess the tax implications of selling an investment property versus holding it. 


Making the wrong move can mean paying unnecessary capital gains tax (CGT) or holding a property that no longer aligns with your financial goals. 


Before you decide, it’s important to understand the numbers behind both options. 

  

What happens tax wise if you sell?


When you sell an investment property, the main tax consideration is capital gains tax (CGT). 


Your capital gain is generally calculated as: 


Sale price – Purchase price – Eligible costs 


Eligible costs may include: 


  • Stamp duty 

  • Legal fees 

  • Selling agent fees 

  • Capital improvements 


If you’ve owned the property for more than 12 months, individuals and trusts may be eligible for the 50% capital gains tax discount. 


However, selling can significantly increase your taxable income in that financial year. This may push you into a higher marginal tax bracket and increase the overall tax payable. 


Before selling, you should model: 


  • Your estimated capital gain 

  • Your total taxable income for the year of sale 

  • Whether delaying the sale to a different financial year could reduce tax 


Timing can make a substantial difference. 

 

When holding an investment property makes more sense


Holding may be the better strategy if: 


  • The property is located in a strong long term growth area 

  • The rental income supports manageable cash flow 

  • Selling would trigger a large capital gains tax bill 

  • You are focused on long term wealth creation 


From a tax perspective, holding allows you to: 


  • Continue claiming depreciation deductions 

  • Claim ongoing interest expenses 

  • Defer capital gains tax 


Deferring CGT can be powerful. If your income is expected to decrease in future years, such as approaching retirement, selling later may result in a lower tax outcome. 


Holding is not about avoiding decisions. It is about ensuring the property still fits your strategy. 

 

Should you sell and buy another investment property instead?


Some investors consider selling in order to upgrade or expand their portfolio. 


Buying another investment property may make sense if: 


  • You have sufficient borrowing capacity 

  • Your cash flow can support additional debt 

  • Your ownership structure is appropriate 


However, buying without reviewing your tax position can create inefficiencies. 


Important factors to assess include: 


  • Land tax exposure 

  • Ownership structure (personal name, trust or company) 

  • Risk management and asset protection 

  • After tax cash flow 


Property investment should be strategic, not reactive. 

 

Common mistakes when deciding to sell or hold


We often see investors make decisions based on emotion rather than analysis. 


Common mistakes include: 


  • Selling due to short term market fear 

  • Ignoring capital gains tax implications 

  • Failing to model after tax outcomes 

  • Forgetting selling costs and transaction expenses 

  • Making decisions without aligning to long term goals 


The right answer depends on your income, risk tolerance, life stage and broader financial plan. 

 

What should you do before making a decision?


Before you sell or hold your investment property, we recommend: 


  • Calculating your estimated capital gains tax 

  • Reviewing your cash flow position 

  • Assessing long term growth potential 

  • Considering alternative strategies such as refinancing 

  • Aligning your decision with your overall wealth plan 


Tax should not be the only factor in your decision, but it should always be considered. 

 

Need help deciding whether to sell or hold?


If you’re unsure whether selling or holding your investment property makes more sense tax wise, Rise Accountants our team of Brisbane accountants can help you with the numbers before you commit. 


Frequently Asked Questions


Should I sell or hold my investment property?

There isn't one answer that suits every investor. Consider the property's cash flow, expected growth, borrowing costs, potential CGT, selling costs and how the property fits with your longer-term wealth strategy.

Selling a rental property can trigger Capital Gains Tax. Broadly, the capital gain or loss reflects the difference between the property's relevant cost base and what you receive when you dispose of it. The cost base can include certain costs associated with acquiring, holding, improving and selling the property.

For CGT purposes, the relevant event generally occurs when you enter into the contract to sell, not at settlement. This can be particularly important when a contract and settlement fall into different financial years.

The property's CGT cost base can include eligible incidental costs such as stamp duty, legal fees and real estate agent commissions, as well as qualifying capital expenditure on improvements. Amounts you've already claimed, or could claim, as tax deductions generally aren't included again in the cost base.

Generally, simply continuing to own the property doesn't trigger CGT. The tax consequence usually arises when a CGT event occurs, such as selling the property. Holding may therefore defer the CGT event, but tax shouldn't be the only reason to keep an investment that no longer suits your strategy.

Not necessarily. Higher repayments are important, but review the property's after-tax cash flow, rental income, long-term prospects, equity and your overall borrowing capacity before deciding. Selling purely in response to short-term conditions can overlook the property's longer-term role in your portfolio.

It can make sense where another property better fits your investment strategy, but factor in CGT, agent and legal costs, new acquisition costs, borrowing capacity and the expected cash flow of the replacement property before proceeding.

Yes. A capital gain can increase taxable income in the year the relevant CGT event occurs. Your broader income and circumstances can therefore make timing relevant, although commercial and investment considerations should remain part of the decision.

Keep records relating to the purchase, stamp duty, legal fees, settlement, ownership costs, repairs, capital improvements and eventual sale costs. The Australian Taxation Office says relevant property records generally need to be kept for at least five years after disposal.

You may be entitled to a full or partial main residence exemption depending on the property's history and how it was used. This is worth reviewing before selling, particularly if the property was your home before becoming a rental.

I'd model at least:


  • Estimated sale proceeds and selling costs

  • Estimated CGT position

  • After-tax amount remaining after the sale

  • Current rental cash flow

  • Expected future holding costs

  • Equity in the property

  • Alternative uses for the sale proceeds

  • The impact on your borrowing capacity and wider investment strategy

Ideally, before signing a sale contract. Because the CGT event generally occurs when the contract is entered into rather than at settlement, getting advice beforehand gives you a clearer understanding of the likely tax outcome while you still have options.



Subscribe to our newsletter

bottom of page