I’m a Medical Consultant - How do I know if I need a Company or Sole Trader Set Up?
Updated: Nov 12

1. Tax Planning and Flexibility
Sole Trader
Income is taxed at individual tax rates.
If your consulting income is high, you may find yourself in the upper tax brackets.
Simpler tax filings, but fewer planning tools.
Company
Income is taxed at the company tax rate (currently lower than the top individual brackets).
You can pay yourself through wages or dividends.
Offers more options for structured cash flow planning.
2. Personal Liability
Sole Trader
You and the business are legally the same.
Personal assets may be exposed if there is legal action or debt.
Insurance is essential to reduce risk.
Company
A company is a separate legal entity.
Your personal assets are generally better protected (separate from any medical indemnity matters, which have their own rules).
Directors still have certain responsibilities, but overall protection is stronger than a sole trader setup.
3. Professional Requirements for Medical Practitioners
Some medical consultants must check alignment with ATO guidelines on personal services income (PSI).
PSI can limit some tax planning strategies, especially around income splitting.
The structure needs to be chosen carefully so it complies with ATO rules for medical consultants.
4. Costs and Administration
Sole Trader
Very low cost to set up.
Minimal ASIC obligations.
Basic bookkeeping and tax compliance.
Company
More expensive to start and run.
Annual ASIC fees and company tax returns.
Requires proper payroll setup if you pay yourself wages.
Bookkeeping standards need to be higher.
5. Professional Image and Growth
Sole Trader
Simple and suitable if you’re consulting on your own with no plans to expand.
Branding can still be strong, but the structure is basic.
Company
Seen as more formal and established.
Easier to bring on contractors, employees or partners later.
Helps when working with hospitals, clinics or agencies that prefer contracting with companies.
6. Superannuation and Insurance
Both structures allow you to contribute to super, but operation differs:
Sole traders can claim personal contributions.
Companies can pay super as employer contributions, which can be smoother for planning.
Insurance (professional indemnity, public liability, income protection) applies to both, but the type and level may differ depending on how your contracts are structured.
So Which Structure Suits a Medical Consultant Best?
Sole trader works well if you want low costs, low admin and you’re starting with smaller engagements.
Company suits those with higher income, broader risk exposure, plans to expand or a desire for stronger asset protection and more controlled tax planning.
Not sure which structure fits you best? The team at Rise Accountants can help you determine whether a sole trader or company structure is going to suit your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should a medical consultant operate as a sole trader or company?
There isn't one structure that's best for every medical consultant. A sole trader structure can offer lower setup costs and simpler administration, while a company is a separate legal entity with additional compliance obligations and may provide greater flexibility as the consulting business grows.
Is a sole trader structure suitable for a medical consultant?
It can be, particularly when starting out independently with relatively simple consulting arrangements. As a sole trader, business income is reported through your individual tax return and the individual and business aren't separate legal entities.
What are the benefits of using a company as a medical consultant?
A company can provide a more formal structure, separation between the individual and business, and additional flexibility when employing staff or expanding the consultancy. However, companies also involve additional administration, company tax returns and ASIC obligations.
Does setting up a company automatically reduce a medical consultant's tax?
No. This is particularly important for medical professionals because Personal Services Income (PSI) rules may apply. The Australian Taxation Office says PSI can include income earned by medical practitioners where more than 50% of the income is mainly a reward for the individual's skills or efforts. PSI can be earned directly as a sole trader or through a company, partnership or trust.
What is Personal Services Income for medical consultants?
PSI is income produced mainly from an individual's personal skills or efforts. Consulting and professional medical income can therefore fall within the PSI rules depending on the circumstances.
Can medical consultants retain their income inside a company?
Not simply because a company receives the consulting fees. Where PSI rules apply, they can affect how income is ultimately attributed and what deductions are available. The ATO requires PSI received through companies to be specifically reported in the company tax return.
Does a company provide better asset protection for medical consultants?
A company is a separate legal entity, which can provide greater separation between personal and business liabilities than operating as a sole trader. However, this doesn't remove professional responsibility or replace appropriate medical indemnity and other insurance.
Is a company worth it for a medical consultant planning to grow?
Potentially. If you intend to employ staff, engage contractors, expand your services or develop a broader medical consulting business, a company may offer useful structural flexibility. The additional setup, bookkeeping, payroll and annual compliance costs still need to be considered.
Can a medical consultant contribute to super as a sole trader?
Yes. Sole traders can make personal super contributions, while a company can make employer contributions where relevant. The appropriate approach will depend on the structure and circumstances.
Can I change from sole trader to a company later?
Potentially. Many consultants begin with a simpler structure and review it as income, risk and operations grow. However, changing structure can have tax, legal and administrative consequences, so it's better to review the change before transferring contracts or business assets.
When should a medical consultant review their business structure?
Consider a review when income increases significantly, you're taking on greater commercial risk, employing staff, signing larger contracts or planning to expand beyond your own personal services. PSI should also form part of that review.
When should I speak to an accountant about my medical consulting structure?
Ideally, before setting up the business or signing significant consulting contracts. The way income is generated can affect PSI, tax and the suitability of your chosen structure, so establishing a company first doesn't necessarily create the expected tax outcome.




